Home / Buy vs rent vs flying club
Buy vs rent vs flying club
Owning has big fixed costs; renting has none. The question is how many hours you fly.
Formula
Rent = rate × hours. Club = buy-in ÷ years + dues × 12 + club rate × hours. Own = fixed + hourly × hours. Own beats rent above fixed ÷ (rent rate − own hourly) hours. AOPA's 172 example found own vs rent break-even just under 100 hours a year against a $135 rental.
Defaults: $176/hr wet rental (Aviatize: $150–$210, often about $175). Club defaults are assumptions inside published club rates ($50–$251/mo dues; 172 at $94–$145/hr wet). Owning ignores equity in the airplane, depreciation and the down payment.
Sources
- AOPA: Hypothetical operating cost calculation (1975 Cessna 172M: insurance $1,200/yr, hangar $250/mo, 8 gph, maintenance $25/hr at 100 h or $13.34/hr at 300 h, engine reserve $17/hr; total $225/hr at 100 h, $108/hr at 300 h; own vs rent break-even just under 100 h/yr vs a $135/hr wet rental)
- Aviatize: flying club vs renting vs owning (C172 wet rental $150–$210/hr, often ~$175; club dues a few dozen to a couple hundred dollars a month)
- Published club rates: Hokie Flying Club ($50/mo dues, 172M $94.39/hr wet, July 2026), Hillsboro Flying Club ($251/mo, 172 $145/hr, Sep 2026), Flywell ($179/mo, $7,500 share, 172N $96/hr)
Common questions
How many hours do I need to fly to justify owning?
It depends on your fixed costs and the local rental rate. AOPA's 172 example broke even just under 100 hours a year. With low fixed costs (tie-down, no loan) it can be lower; with a loan and a hangar it is often much higher.
Is a flying club cheaper than renting?
Usually, if you fly more than a couple of dozen hours a year. Clubs split fixed costs among members, so hourly rates are closer to direct operating cost.